Can Einstein handle 3.5 PFlops offered by NVIDIA's K20? Cuz I'm thinking about buying one.

ForumsCruncher's Corner

gabefair
gabefair
Joined: 30 Dec 08
Posts: 2
Credit: 10820360
RAC: 4123
Topic 196863

NVIDIA's K20 GPU has 2496 CUDA cores and offers a Peak single precision floating point performance (board): 3.52 Tflops for only 225 watts!

My question is, Can Einstein use all of those cores if I were to buy one? Would this GPU be used fully?

What would happen to the Einstein@Home community if one or two of the GPUs were to come online?

MAGIC Quantum Mechanic
MAGIC Quantum M...
Joined: 18 Jan 05
Posts: 1061
Credit: 281166960
RAC: 239152

Can Einstein handle 3.5 PFlops offered by NVIDIA's K20? Cuz I'm

Well I wouldn't mind testing one here as long as it has MB with 16GB ram and the fastest multi-core CPU I could have at the same time.

It would cost about the same as buying 11 nVidia GeForce GTX 660Ti 2GB SC

And I have found out that the cards I have act different (slower) if I try to run BRP X2 along with 4 GRP's (or 3 with a 3-core)

My 650Ti SC is running with one of my older 3-core and it does ok until I tried to run the 3GRP's but I have it;s twin running with a 550TI OC and it was still doing ok running the GRP's at the same time (no free cores)

The 660Ti runs ok that way too.

Funny thing is the laptop I am on right now runs BRP X2 cudas and 8 GRP's at the same time 24/7 for almost a year now and it runs just fine without a free core.

So like I said I get tempted to test cards like that Tesla K20 but I wouldn't be surprised if it doesn't do what you would hope for when you pay $3,499

Horacio
Horacio
Joined: 3 Oct 11
Posts: 205
Credit: 80557243
RAC: 0

I cant know in advance if

I cant know in advance if that GPU is worth for number crunching, but for sure it wont affect the project in any way...
The project was able to handle the massive power of lots of GPUs some time ago when SETI was offline, so just one extra GPU is not going to be noticed, no matter how fast is.

But, if you are considering that GPU just for number crunching in Einstein, then I fear you will be dissapointed... Teslas have a really high cost because their speed on double pressicion which is not needed on Einstein.

Neil Newell
Neil Newell
Joined: 20 Nov 12
Posts: 176
Credit: 169699457
RAC: 0

...plus they are engineered

...plus they are engineered for reliability over outright speed, so clocked slower and use ECC RAM.

Probably better to spend the money on GTX Titan - less than 1/3 the price, and 2688 cores.

microchip
microchip
Joined: 10 Jun 06
Posts: 48
Credit: 6947269
RAC: 0

Yeah, I also recommend the

Yeah, I also recommend the Titan over a Tesla. Over at GPUGRID they're working on an application that will run optimal on the Titan. No idea if this is needed for Einstein too (my guess it isn't)

mountkidd
mountkidd
Joined: 14 Jun 12
Posts: 104
Credit: 646258486
RAC: 267195

For E@H GPU processing,

For E@H GPU processing, buswidth and bandwidth appear to have a much greater impact than core count. GTX 670/680 are close in bandwidth, GFlops/Watt to the K20 and almost an order of magnitude lower in cost. If raw power is what you are after consider the HD7970 as its bandwidth is ~30% higher than the 3 cards mentioned above and is spec'd at 3.7 TFlops.

Gord

mikey
mikey
Joined: 22 Jan 05
Posts: 2607
Credit: 166037530
RAC: 172213

RE: For E@H GPU processing,

Quote:

For E@H GPU processing, buswidth and bandwidth appear to have a much greater impact than core count. GTX 670/680 are close in bandwidth, GFlops/Watt to the K20 and almost an order of magnitude lower in cost. If raw power is what you are after consider the HD7970 as its bandwidth is ~30% higher than the 3 cards mentioned above and is spec'd at 3.7 TFlops.

Gord

I can't say about Einstein but I CAN say the AMD 7970 gpu is SCREAMINGLY fast!! Comparing it to the 5770 it replaced I went from doing units in about 1.5 hours to 10 MINUTES!! I am using it at DistRTgen so I do not even know if it CAN work here, there are some projects that just haven't made it work for them yet.

Mike Hewson
Mike Hewson
Joined: 1 Dec 05
Posts: 5105
Credit: 42018264
RAC: 6922

RE: What would happen to

Quote:
What would happen to the Einstein@Home community if one or two of the GPUs were to come online?


We'd be very happy !

Never knock back a petaflop, that's what I always say ... :-) :-)

IMHO the Titan specs are awesome, especially as Neil says on the reliability side but also power use. Naturally it's performance is subject to moderation by the system it's in. Having said that though it is a major outlay for anybody, definitely a bleeding edge item. It'll be the most expensive single item within the case for sure.

[musings]

Quote:
I think we're moving/merging toward an era of 'massively parallel coprocessors, some of which also do graphics'. By that I mean I'm not aware of an application that would purely use such a card to the full extent of it graphics performance alone. Could well be my ignorance, but many FPS can you justify for some video game or 3D visualisation ? Does anyone know of an example ? This is relevant in that for such an outlay, is there a business ( non-supercomputing ) purpose that justifies the purchase per se, and can maybe do E@H et al on the side .....

[/musings]

Cheers, Mike.

( edit ) Wow, they're talking 3-way SLI here.

"I have made this letter longer than usual, because I lack the time to make it short." - Blaise Pascal

Gamboleer
Gamboleer
Joined: 5 Dec 10
Posts: 173
Credit: 127641906
RAC: 382744

> Fire and brimstone

>

Fire and brimstone coming down from the skies! Rivers and seas boiling! Forty years of darkness! Earthquakes! Volcanoes! The dead rising from the grave! Human sacrifice! Dogs and cats living together! Mass hysteria!

HenkM
HenkM
Joined: 29 Sep 09
Posts: 32
Credit: 165023169
RAC: 0

If you have a look

If you have a look here
http://einsteinathome.org/host/5728548/tasks&offset=0&show_names=1&state=3&appid=0
choosing between AMD/ATI 7970 and Nvidea Titan is easy in my opinion.
Here in NL a 7970 costs just halve of a Titan.

Nobody316
Nobody316
Joined: 14 Jan 13
Posts: 141
Credit: 2008126
RAC: 0

http://www.newegg.com/Product

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814131483&IsVirtualParent=1

PowerColor AX7990 6GBD5-2DHJ Radeon HD 7990 6GB 384-bit x2 GDDR5 PCI Express 3.0 x16 HDCP Ready CrossFireX Support Video Card looks quite nice.

Quote:
Revolutionize your gaming experience with the PowerColor AX7990 VGA card. Powered by dual class-leading AMD Radeon HD 7970 engines, the PowerColor AX7990 tackles your most demanding HD titles with monstrous performance from 2048 x 2 Stream Processors and total of 6GB 384-bit x 2 GDDR5 memory. Your games cease to be the same with redefined realism and skip-free experience even at the highest setting. Dual BIOS design enables you to push the performance potential to limit with a press of one button. An array of AMD graphics technology such as AMD Eyefinity, AMD HD 3D and AMD PowerTune offers you more than one way to elevate your gaming experience.

The price is not too bad either but it looks like it would be cheaper just to buy 2 of the 7970 cards unless ya buy 2 of the 7990 which would = 4 of the 7970's. I agree the 7970 seems quite fast and will be something I will be checking out in the near future.

PC setup MSI-970A-G46 AMD FX-8350 8 core OC'd 4.45GHz 16GB ram PC3-10700 Geforce GTX 650Ti Windows 7 x64 Einstein@Home

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.