The coming distributed processing explosion

Matt Giwer
Matt Giwer
Joined: 12 Dec 05
Posts: 144
Credit: 6,891,649
RAC: 0

RE: I had to install

Message 99638 in response to message 99636

Quote:
I had to install gcc-fortran, blas and lapack this morning just to compile an "octave" package, a kind of open-source Matlab, to run some setiquest programs. All went fine but I must install also gnuplot.
Tullio

"kinda like" I once took a quick look through a book which claimed to be a guide for learning both Matlab and Octave. There was exactly one page on the two or three differences. One was the Octave could take both single and double quotes to the same meaning. Since then I have been wondering if MATLAB was other than a repackaged Octave sort of like Redhat's Enterprise v Fedora releases.

Matt Giwer
Matt Giwer
Joined: 12 Dec 05
Posts: 144
Credit: 6,891,649
RAC: 0

RE: @Matt: the simple

Message 99639 in response to message 99637

Quote:

@Matt: the simple answer is.. it depends!

For the current Einstein app it's not of much use to discuss GPU performance, as it uses only a rather small fraction of the GPU anyway. You can use one GPU for several instances of this app (see the other current thread), so adding more GPUs is nor really going to help (unless you've got really many cores, say a Quad AMD 12 core or so). You need a mid to high end GPU though, in order not to slow down the CPU. The slower the CPU the slower the GPU can be.
...

MrS

The only help that was was to outline what I have to learn to talk on this subject coherently -- I hope. Thanks for the time.

What I can add at this moment is the motherboards used by HP with nVidia chips are not recognized by the benchmark test and so are not used.

ExtraTerrestrial Apes
ExtraTerrestria...
Joined: 10 Nov 04
Posts: 769
Credit: 187,482,696
RAC: 175,149

RE: Since then I have been

Message 99640 in response to message 99638

Quote:
Since then I have been wondering if MATLAB was other than a repackaged Octave sort of like Redhat's Enterprise v Fedora releases.

No. Octave takes the basic language elements of Matlab, omits the graphical part (not sure how much it can do here) and distributes it for free. Matlab is much more than that.

MrS

Scanning for our furry friends since Jan 2002

Bikeman (Heinz-Bernd Eggenstein)
Bikeman (Heinz-...
Moderator
Joined: 28 Aug 06
Posts: 3,516
Credit: 460,264,318
RAC: 19,003

Octave uses gnuplot for

Message 99641 in response to message 99640

Octave uses gnuplot for graphics, and is pretty Matlab-compatible by now.

CU
HBE

tullio
tullio
Joined: 22 Jan 05
Posts: 2,046
Credit: 40,820,335
RAC: 15,936

I've compiled the 3.3.52

I've compiled the 3.3.52 version of Octave, which is a development version, and added gnuplot, which I already knew. Now I must find what to do with it. I've been visiting the www.setiquest.org site but my programmer's skills are not up to what they look for.
Tullio

Matt Giwer
Matt Giwer
Joined: 12 Dec 05
Posts: 144
Credit: 6,891,649
RAC: 0

RE: RE: Since then I have

Message 99643 in response to message 99640

Quote:
Quote:
Since then I have been wondering if MATLAB was other than a repackaged Octave sort of like Redhat's Enterprise v Fedora releases.

No. Octave takes the basic language elements of Matlab, omits the graphical part (not sure how much it can do here) and distributes it for free. Matlab is much more than that.

MrS

Never used Octave -- one of those things I'd like to play with some day. Also a pirate copy of Matlab (I did not say that. I was not here.) but never played with that either. Love the idea of same syntax though should I find a use for it. What little math I fool with these days is not amenable to standard formulations -- such as animation paths and near field radiation patterns. Luckily retirement does not require me to produce anything on schedule.

Anyway, I have baselines for two of my three machines but want to install the nVidia card in the one still without a baseline -- just added it 16 days ago -- as it is the fastest CPU clock and with four Athlon II cores. I expect to be impressed enough to buy GPU cards for the other two machines but I want to see the baseline change when I do it.

BTW: Has there been any reasonable suggestion as to why mobo nVidia chips to not register?

Mike Hewson
Mike Hewson
Moderator
Joined: 1 Dec 05
Posts: 6,126
Credit: 128,352,226
RAC: 33,862

The 'Mat' in Matlab is

The 'Mat' in Matlab is 'matrix', so especially suits mathematical problems expressible in such terms. But one can still do many things you wouldn't immediately consider matrix-like. After all a real scalar is a 1 x 1 matrix. I find it way less daunting than Mathematica, which is somewhat 'uber' by comparison ( cost notably ). The graphical part of Matlab is gorgeous ...... :-)

Cheers, Mike.

I have made this letter longer than usual because I lack the time to make it shorter. Blaise Pascal

tullio
tullio
Joined: 22 Jan 05
Posts: 2,046
Credit: 40,820,335
RAC: 15,936

In LOGO a scalar is a list

In LOGO a scalar is a list with one element, a vector is a list with two or more elements,a matrix is a list of lists. Too bad it is slow, being an interpreted language.
Tullio

ExtraTerrestrial Apes
ExtraTerrestria...
Joined: 10 Nov 04
Posts: 769
Credit: 187,482,696
RAC: 175,149

RE: I expect to be

Message 99646 in response to message 99643

Quote:
I expect to be impressed enough to buy GPU cards for the other two machines but I want to see the baseline change when I do it.

What do you mean by baseline? And don't expect much from the current Einstein CUDA V2 app.

Quote:
BTW: Has there been any reasonable suggestion as to why mobo nVidia chips to not register?

What do you mean by "to not register"?

MrS

Scanning for our furry friends since Jan 2002

Matt Giwer
Matt Giwer
Joined: 12 Dec 05
Posts: 144
Credit: 6,891,649
RAC: 0

RE: RE: I expect to be

Message 99647 in response to message 99646

Quote:
Quote:
I expect to be impressed enough to buy GPU cards for the other two machines but I want to see the baseline change when I do it.

What do you mean by baseline? And don't expect much from the current Einstein CUDA V2 app.

I mean I want to see what I get as an RAC before attempting to increase its performance. That way I hope to get a feel for what the improvement is worth. I also intend to look into cost/performance eventually as in does a $100 card to most of what two cards in crossfire or not. In other words to find a point of diminishing returns.

Quote:
Quote:
BTW: Has there been any reasonable suggestion as to why mobo nVidia chips to not register?

What do you mean by "to not register"?

MrS

I meant Do not register. I have nVidia chips on the mobo of one machine but the test of the computer replies "no GPUs" and thus are not used.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.